Build Magazine June 2015

Build Magazine 22 The ‘legacy’ of hosting a major sporting event, such as the FIFA World Cup or the Olympics, is the prevailing argument made by host countries to justify the huge expense of the event. South Africa, Brazil, and Qatar have all stated that hosting the World Cup would pro- vide their countries with significant progress towards their development goals, including poverty alleviation, infrastructure provision, increase in public sector investment, and job creation. However, it is increasingly suggest- ed that the lasting impact of major events does not justify the massive expense. New research from Saïd Business School, University of Oxford, shows how the manage- ment of the South Africa 2010 FIFA World Cup stadium programme shaped the current legacy of an oversupply of overdesigned and underused stadiums. Dr Eamon Molloy, Associate Fellow at Saïd Business School, and Trish Chetty, Director at K40 Group and alumna of the MSc in Major Programme Management at Saïd Business School, found that the South African stadium programme for the World Cup adopted a fragmented approach to building stadiums from the bid stage. They concluded that the lack of a single clear strategy that integrated all of the stadium projects into one major programme was the critical factor in the discord between the expected legacy and the reality. The research identifies seven main factors that explain the disparity be- tween the expected benefits and the legacy outcome in the South African stadium programme: • Overoptimistic estimating • Lack of national direction on funding • Political decision making, that took precedence over economic rational decision making • Unclear requirements from FIFA, including lack of knowledge about the complexity of hosting the World Cup • Focus on technical overdesign beyond the country’s needs • Opportunities for collusion and corruption • Failure to engage key stakeholders The final stadiums used for the South African FIFA World Cup were six new and four existing upgraded stadiums. Instead of the economic growth the stadiums were intended to stimulate, six newly built stadiums all have annual The True Legacy of Building Stadiums for the FIFA World Cup New research from Saïd Business School identifies the seven key factors that led to overdesigned and under-utilised stadiums after the FIFA 2010 World Cup in South Africa. N

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy NTg0MjY1